The comment of the reviewer of the graduate work The theme of the graduate work:  “The modern processes in the landscape of the Northwestern Priladogie” Author: Voskresenskaya V.A., The Sciences of the Earth Institute (Sanct-Petersburg State University) Department: The physical geography and the planning of landscape The main education programm: The Physical Geography Level: Master programm Scientific supervisor: Isachenko G.A., assistant professor, cand.of geogr.sciences reviewer: Volkova Ye.A., Botanic Science Institute (of The Science Academy of the Russia Federation), cand.of botan.sciences THE EVALUATION OF THE COMPLIANCE WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE QUALIFICATION OF THE AUTHOR OF THIS GRADUATE WORK The actuality of the theme of graduate work: 5 The level of the fullness of the review of the specific problem and the level of the accuracy of the assigned task: 4 The level of the accuracy of the using of the research’ methods, the methods of mathematic modeling, the methods of calculations and etc.: 5 The level of complicity of the graduate work, the level of the using of the common-professional and specific subjects: 5 The level of the clearness, accuracy, the logic way of the studying, the consistency and the argumentation of the account: 4 The using of the modern soft-programs, including mapping program with using GIS and others technologies: 5 The quality of the presentation of the graduate work (the level of grammar, the style of  account , the quality of the illustration, the compliance with the standard requirements): 3 The volumes and the quality of the presentation of the graphical materials, its relevance to the text: 4 The originality  and the newness of the obtained results, of the scientific and practical conclusions: 5 The level of the independence of the graduate work: 5  The determined values of the graduate work: In the graduate work of Voskresenskya V.A. there was analyzed the massive volume of the data of the field’s studying, which have created the base for the good research, for the proper conclusions of the modern processes in the landscape and for the realistic prognoses of the landscape’s dynamic in the next 50 years. The student of Master program has demonstrated the using of the methods of the field’s and cameral  studying. The mapping of the “modern processes” and of the “scenario of the dynamic of the changing of the landscape during the next 50 years in condition of the absence of anthropogenic influence” – is the very profitable material of independent stuying.   The determined lacks of the graduate work: The description of the ecological floristical groups of the  vascular  kinds of the plants needs in revision  - some kinds of the plants were not named under their groups. The author should be use the one color scale for the determination of the all ecological floristical groups in the illustration of the diagrams of the absolute and of the relevant total capacity of the different groups  of the plants, so it can be more easy way for their compering. The graduate work has a lot of typo, grammar and stylistic mistakes      The conclusion of the reviewer: The graduate work of Voskresenskaya V.A. is valuated on 4 score. In the case of the approving of the done research, the graduate work can be estimated more higher, because it consists the valuable scientific material, the newness of the scientific results. So the author is worthy of the highest score, because the main lacks of the graduate work are connected with it’s presentation.   reviewer: Volkova Yelena Anatolyevna May the 5th of 2016