1. Clarity of setting goals and objectives of the study    The formulation of the goals and objectives of the study was carried out in accordance with    problems identified in the final qualifying work. The content of the work corresponds to the stated subject. 2. The validity of the structure and logic of the study    The structure of the work, the logic and the order of the research are corresponding to    goals and tasks of the final qualifying work. 3. Presence of the author's contribution to the research results Amyaga V.V. in his work analyzed a large number of sources    information. As a result of this analysis, the author of the work was    identified and classified modern theoretical and practical problems in the field of data analysis.    In addition, Amyaga V.V. identified current problems in the    company and proposed recommendations for    improving the process of data analysis. In that work, there is a significant degree of independent results, conclusions and    recommendations applicable to the practice of the company. 4. Novelty and practical importance of the study    The author developed an original model of the data analysis process,    greatly improving the speed and quality of the analysis. Results of the research are introduced into the company and used in its practical    activities. The presented model has allowed reducing development time    applications, improved the quality of the applications being implemented and improved the    process of data analysis in the company.    The results of the final qualifying work can be used in practical activities similar companies. 5. Correctness of the use of methods of research and analysis of economic information    The research methods used by the author are consistent with the    goals and objectives, and also correspond to the logic of scientific work.    The reasoning and conclusions that the author gives in the text of the work are correct,    logical and non-contradictory. 6. The relevance of used information sources    The author has done a lot of work on the analysis of modern trends    research in the field of the final qualifying work. When conducting scientific work    Amyaga V.V. studied advanced research for the period from 2012 to 2018,    which was reflected in the text of the work.    In his work, the author relies on foreign and domestic    theoretical works, as well as articles and magazines of practitioners. 7. Advantages of work    • Urgency and practical importance of the study area    • The text of the work analyzes a large number of scientific papers on      the theme of final qualifying work    • The material outlined is consistent, structured and accessible for      understanding of    • The conclusions and recommendations derived by the author are logical, correct and      consistent 8. Remarks and shortcomings of work    Significant remarks to the final qualifying work, which reduce its practical significance, did not revealed. 9. Questions    What are the limitations when implementing the smart data model? 10. Admission to protection and evaluation of work    Final qualifying work was implemented at a high practical level. In the scientific work,    the author demonstrated his knowledge of the main theoretical positions and    confident possession of practical skills. The work was carried out in accordance with    set goals and contains a high level of practical importance.    Amyaga V.V. deserves an excellent assessment and worthy of the assignment of qualifications in    accordance with the received specialty.